
A slew of big men round out our list from 11-20. Where does Jokic currently stack up in the mix? Who do we think is the most underrated player in NBA history?
20
Isiah Thomas
Isiah led a team that captured an image and toughness maybe never seen again (aside from maybe one other Detroit team 20 years later). Isiah was the ultimate floor general, the starter to the offense. He was the driver to a team that feared no one and won in some of the biggest moments, going toe-to-toe with the likes of Bird, Magic, and Jordan—and one of the few who came out on top multiple times. Thomas never lit up the scorer’s sheet but always seemed to possess an extra gear at the end of games to will his team to victory. Bill Simmons has one of my favorite theories, the “It Theory.” That some players just have “It”—an indescribable or non-measurable thing that makes an athlete special. In his book, he writes how Isiah was the poster child of that. It’s one thing I couldn’t agree with more. Thomas was always one of the best players in the league but clearly was behind Jordan, Magic, and Bird when it came to size, skill, and stats. But at the end of the day, his grittiness, IQ, and skill set made him every bit of their counterparts.
19
Julius Erving
I sadly think Erving is being lost in some historical NBA conversations. Maybe it’s that some of his best years were spent in the ABA. Maybe it’s just the era he played in. Maybe it’s because he only has one NBA championship. All of that to be said, Dr. J is one of the greatest wings of all time. An uber-athletic small forward, he was literally leaps and bounds over his contemporaries in terms of athleticism. The Dr. was an elite scorer who ultimately split time in the ABA pre-merger and came into the NBA, finishing a 16-year career where he captured 3 ABA MVPs, 1 NBA MVP, 2 ABA Championships, 1 NBA Championship, 16 All-Stars, and 12 combined All-ABA/NBA teams. He and Moses Malone (who we will talk about very shortly as well) led the 1983 76ers to one of the most dominant playoff runs in NBA history. Erving is a basketball legend who helped transcend the league to above-the-rim play.
18
Oscar Robertson
Oscar came into the league as the number one overall pick out of Cincinnati and instantly became a triple-double machine. In his second season, he was the first player to average a triple-double and the only player to do it until Russell Westbrook accomplished it over 50 years later. Oscar was Kareem’s running mate in the 1971 Finals to secure the Bucks’ first Finals. Oscar was clearly the best point guard the league had pre-Magic. The only knock on his NBA résumé—which includes 3 MVPs, 1 Championship, 12 All-Stars, 11 All-NBA teams, and 1 scoring title—is that he didn’t win a ring as the best player on his team. Though he was still a top-5 finisher in MVP in 1971, that team was led by league MVP Kareem Abdul-Jabbar. Oscar’s skill set was well ahead of his time. A sizable lead guard at 6’5”, he is one of the few players from the 1960s who wouldn’t skip a beat in any era.
17
Giannis Antetokounmpo
Time will tell how far up this list Giannis will land. The 6’11” Greek Freak has become one of the best athletes and two-way players the league has ever seen. A giant wrecking ball coming down the court, defenses have had to shift to building a barrier or wall as a team to stop Giannis coming down the lane in transition. Giannis’s trophy case is full with 2 MVPs, 1 Championship, 1 Finals MVP, 1 DPOY, along with 9 All-Star and 9 All-NBA selections. Giannis is at a crossroads in Milwaukee. Their championship window closed quickly, and they are trying to reload instead of rebuild. Giannis has shown a ton of loyalty to that city, but what and where will the rest of his career land?
16
Jerry West
One thing I think that often gets overlooked when it comes to these lists is that Jerry West was the best guard scorer in the league until Jordan—and he did it all while being a great jump shooter with no three-point line. Almost 25 years of NBA history went by until a guard could score like West. He is one of four retired players to have a career points-per-game average over 27 (four active players have averages over 27: LeBron James, Kevin Durant, Joel Embiid, and Luka Dončić). West was as tough a competitor as the league has ever seen. He fought against Russell’s Celtics in the 60s but was never able to defeat his Boston foes, even while being the only player in league history to win Finals MVP on the losing team. West was able to claim NBA gold in 1972 on arguably the best team of that decade. West accomplished as much as any guard in league history. He became one of the best front office executives post-playing career and will always live on as the NBA logo.
15
Kevin Durant
Much like Dirk before him, Kevin Durant has shaped the generation of basketball players after him. Listed at 6’11” but most likely a few inches taller, there has never been a more skilled offensive player at his size. Durant is now also putting on a showcase of longevity. After coming into the league as the second pick in the 2007 Draft at 19, Durant is going into year 18 (one full year missed due to an Achilles tear). Durant has never averaged less than 20 points per game, and aside from his rookie season has never averaged less than 25 points per game. He is arguably the best scorer from the wing of all time. Acquiring one league MVP, 2 Finals MVPs, 11 All-NBA, and 15 All-Star selections, the four-time scoring champ has nearly every accolade and trophy an NBA player can get. One knock—or crappy First Take argument—that often comes up with Durant is that his two championships came after joining an already great Warriors team in 2016. Though I see the argument and where it’s based, Durant was arguably the best player in the league his three years in Golden State. And though it is speculative, if he didn’t get hurt in the Finals in 2019, I don’t have much doubt they would have won that series against Toronto. Durant can shoot over everyone, he handles the ball like a guard at 6’11”+, he developed into a good defender, and at age 36 still averaged 26.6 points per game. He finds himself with a very young and talented team in Houston—you have to wonder if he will be able to build off an already incredible career.
14
Moses Malone
I’ll say this with no hesitation: Moses Malone is the most underrated NBA legend of all time, and I don’t think it’s very close. When talking about the great centers of all time, we hear the arguments for some of the next few players on our list—Shaq, Kareem, Wilt, Russell, and Hakeem. But rarely do I hear the name Moses Malone thrown around in that conversation, and I can’t understand why. Moses debuted in the ABA in 1974, and after playing 2 seasons came to the NBA and instantly became a dominant force, capturing his first of three MVPs in just his second year (age 23) in the NBA. Moses dominated the glass for his first decade in the league, leading the league in rebounds per game six times and averaging as many as 17.6 rebounds in the 1978-79 season. As mentioned earlier, Moses led the 1983 76ers to a dominant playoff run and championship, dropping only 1 game the entire playoffs. Was his game as pretty as that of Hakeem and Jokic? No. Was he as dominant of a force physically as Shaq and Wilt? No. But Moses is arguably the greatest rebounder of all time and was the best center of the 1980s.
13
Nikola Jokic
Here is another take I’m saying with no hesitation: Nikola Jokic is the best offensive player ever. Now, part of that I’m projecting he can sustain at least close to the level he has sustained the last 5 seasons. Now just going into his age-30 season, Jokic has been undoubtedly the best player in the NBA for the past 5 years, capturing league MVP three times and finishing second in voting the other two years (you could argue voter fatigue played a role in both or at least one of those second-place finishes). One thing I think often gets overlooked with Jokic’s résumé is he is scoring and creating an elite NBA offense and hasn’t played with an active All-Star one time in his entire 10-year career. Jokic is able to average a near triple-double (did average a triple-double in the 2024-2025 season) from the center position with not one single other All-Star. He led the Nuggets to a championship in 2023 with no other All-Stars. What he is doing no other player in the league’s history could ever do. Coming into the league out of Serbia in the second round (famously, his draft selection was done during a Taco Bell commercial), Jokic is not a physical specimen or built like some of the other great big men like David Robinson, Shaquille O’Neal, or Hakeem Olajuwon—but it doesn’t matter. Jokic controls the offense and pace like no other big man, or really player, in the league ever has. Jokic feels and looks like a player that can age well in this league. As long as he doesn’t decide to retire early to tend to his horses in Serbia, Jokic may be able to climb this list a bit higher if he can get back to hoisting the Larry O’Brien again.
12
Hakeem Olajuwon
Arguably the best two-way player of all time. At this point of the list and the league’s all-time elite, you’re nitpicking between player to player and where they stack up. Hakeem is forever remembered for his graceful footwork and patented Dream Shake and repertoire of post moves. Hakeem came into the league as the number one pick in the 1984 Draft and quickly became one of the league’s best centers. His two-way dominance is showcased by his 12 All-Star and All-NBA appearances, along with 9 All-Defensive Teams and 3-time shot block leader titles (he is also the all-time leader in blocked shots and averaged over 4 blocks per game 3 times in his career). Olajuwon’s crowning accomplishment came in the 1993-1994 season, where he not only claimed his lone league MVP but also became the only player to win the Finals, league MVP, Finals MVP, and Defensive Player of the Year award all in the same season. Olajuwon stood out as the league’s best center of the 1990s, taking the torch from Moses and passing it to Shaq.
11
Wilt Chamberlain
We talk about crazy stat lines and the most mesmerizing Basketball Reference pages, and Wilt is by far the champion of that. Whether it was averaging 50 points in a season, averaging over 30 points per game for his career, averaging 22.9 rebounds for his career, or averaging 8.6 assists in a season, Wilt never lacked the numbers. He was the most talented player of the 1960s compared to his adversaries of Jerry West, Oscar Robertson, and of course his toughest foe, Bill Russell. The legacy of Wilt, to me, often comes down to this: if he was the most talented, why did he only win one championship as the best player on his team? Remember back to Isiah Thomas—he had that “It” intangible. Something intangible, something that doesn’t show up on the back of a basketball card. Wilt had all the talent, was one of the most charismatic personalities, an athletic marvel—but I often think and read that he lacked “it.” He was more talented than Russell on the offensive end of the floor by leaps and bounds. But he was only able to capture one championship in the 60s when the two of them battled. Again, when we get to this point in ranking NBA greats, we are getting super nitpicky. Wilt is arguably the most gifted athlete the league has ever seen; no one will ever eclipse his scoring records. A seven-time scoring champ, 13-time All-Star, and 4-time league MVP, he is more of an NBA god than anything else.









